Playing Pretend Got Gayer 5

Playing Pretend Just Got A Lot Gayer: Part 5



I woke up the next morning at round eight again, and once again did my morning routine. I was ready to leave when I heard a knock at my door. I opened the door to see Cody leaning against the wall adjacent to my door.

“Hey baby.” Cody said giving me a long kiss on the lips. I smiled and glanced around only to see Eva walking towards the elevator.

“Good morning to you too.” I said smiling and tilting his chin up to kiss him again. When I pulled away I noticed Eva had left. I smiled bigger.

“Well played! High five dude!” Cody said holding his hand up. I rolled my eyes and decided to humor him by slapping his hand.

“So you come to my room just for that?”

“Actually I want to talk to you; you mind?” he asked pointing inside my room.

I shrugged and we walked into my room. I sat down on my bed and he followed suit.

“So what did you want to talk about?” I was a bit worried; I mean normally when talking is mentioned it leads to a breakup, and I really couldn’t afford that with Eva around.

“Nothing big; just our plans for the day.”

“We have plans?” I raised an eyebrow.

“Not plans exactly. I mean I have an idea.”

“And that idea is...”

“Okay so the physical stuff is pissing Eva off, but I was thinking, what’s the most annoying thing new couples do?”

“Spend every waking moment together?”

“Well, that’s annoying too, but I was thinking about the lovey way they talk to each other.”

“Oh.”

“Yeah so I was thinking we could totally piss Eva off if we started acting like the typical lovey-dovey high school couple. If we do that and some physical stuff I really think we can make her cry.” Cody said in an excited voice.

“When did you become such a little asshole?”

“I’m not an asshole! I just think someone should put her in her place, that’s all.” He said crossing his arms.

“Okay my little asshole; little asshole is a loving nickname, right?” I said smiling. He punched my arm playfully.

“I don’t think it’s what we’re looking for.” He said rolling his eyes at me.

“It was worth a try.” I said shrugging.

“So you think it’s a good idea then?”

“Yeah, maybe if she thinks I’m in love with you she’ll stop watching me.”

“Y-yeah, maybe.” Why is he blushing? What did I say this time?

“What?”

“N-nothing. I was just thinking that we shouldn’t say ‘I love you’ because couples who do that when they first start dating always end up breaking up in a week. So I think if we don’t say it yet it’ll make us look more serious about each other.”  

“Okay.”

“Good so let’s go piss Eva off!”

“Yeah!” I shouted sarcastically; not that Cody knew I was being sarcastic.

We walked out of my room holding hands and soon entered the elevator, only to have the luck of Justin already being on it.

“If it isn’t the anti-me.”

“Good to see you to, Noah. Congratulations on the new boyfriend; he’s cute.” I scowled at him. He was trying to piss me off and it was working.

I turned away from Justin; now wasn’t the time for our final battle.

“Aw are you ignoring me? How cute; guess I know who’s wearing the pants in this relationship.”

I kept ignoring him as I looked toward the lights on the elevator. We were on the seventh floor. This was the longest elevator ride I’d ever had.

I watched Justin walk toward Cody, who looked stunned.

“That’s a nice hicky Cody, but if you ever want a better one you can always ask me.” Justin said touching the mark on Cody’s neck. That was the last straw; fake boyfriend or not nobody was going to hit on him in front of me. I let go of Cody’s hand and stood between Justin and Cody.

“Don’t touch what doesn’t belong to you.” I growled out in a voice I didn’t know I possessed.

“What Noah; afraid he’d like someone else better?”

“Back off Justin.”

“Why Noah? Is it because you know my looks beat your smarts any day? Or is it because you know he’d choose me over you?”

“You aren’t even gay.” I said getting into his face.

Justin leaned in by my ear and whispered so only I could hear. “Neither are you. And I’m going to prove it.”

I punched Justin in the face. He simple looked at me; it was obvious I hadn’t done much damage assuming I did any.

“Cute Noah.” Justin said walking out of the newly stopped elevator.

I was seething mad at this point and ready to go after him; except that I felt a tug on my arm.

“What the hell was that?” Cody asked pulling me in the opposite direction of Justin.

“He knows I’m not gay, and he wants to prove it.”

“Well he can’t; there’s no way that he can. We just have to kick this thing into high gear, and keep it that way. And dude, nice work on the possessive thing on the elevator.”

“Yeah.” I wish it had been an act.

“Come on.” Cody said pulling my arm towards the bar where Katie and Sadie sat staring at Justin at the other side of the resort.

We both sat down and got our usual drinks.

“Aww, look Katie, it’s Cody and Noah! Aren’t they, like, the cutest couple ever!?”

“Um, yeah. They’re really cute together.” Katie said smiling sadly.

I smiled at them in the best way I could.

“So how’s it going Noah?” Katie asked me. I felt sick looking at her. She looked sad, but I knew what I was doing was for the best…For both of us.

“Good, Cody makes me happier than I ever thought I could be.” I faked a smile.

“Well Cody, you’re very lucky to have a guy like Noah.”

“Yeah, I really am.” Cody said grabbing my hand and squeezing it in a reassuring way.

“Oh my gosh, Katie, look Justin is taking his shirt off, let’s go!”

“Bye guys!” Katie said running to catch up with Sadie a real smile on her face.

“Bye.” I said waving.

“Dude I’m sorry, I didn’t think-“

“It’s okay,” I said smiling. “She’ll be fine. I just wish she wasn’t all over Justin again.”

“Don’t worry dude, she’ll realize he’s a jerk sooner or later.”

“Yeah; your right. Now get over here Beth’s coming.”

Cody smiled and climbed onto my lap.

“Hey Cody! Noah.” Beth said smiling. I’d never really talked to Beth; all I knew was that she told off Heather and kissed Cody all in the same day. I felt respect for her.

“Hey Beth!” Cody said leaning back into me. I put my arms around him.

“How are you guys doing?” Beth asked sitting down.

“Good. Of course how could I not be, look whose lap I’m sitting on.” Cody said smiling and bending his head back to place a small kiss on my lips.

“You’re a little suck up aren’t you?” I said licking his ear.

He then stuck his tongue out at me; he does that a lot.

Beth laughed. “I still can’t believe you guys are dating. I just never saw you guys as gay. Which reminds me, I’m sorry I kissed you Cody, I didn’t know.”

“Well I’m actually bi, but it was kinda weird because I totally think of you as a sister.”

“Well at least it was only on the cheek.”

“Yeah.”

“Not like Noah kisses you.” Beth said smirking. Cody blushed hard when she said that.

I chuckled as I rubbed Cody’s right nipple. Cody shivered.

“Cody we’re having a girls sleepover tonight; you should come.”

“But I’m bi.” Cody said confused.

“Yeah, so. Trust me Cody, you should come. Please?”

“Um, okay.” Cody said nervously.

“Noah, do you wanna come?”

“Um, not my thing, but you guys have fun.”

“Okay, if you’re sure. See you tonight Cody!”

When Beth left Cody turned to me.

“You’re making me go alone?” Cody asked with a scared face.

“Well if it makes you feel better it seems like Beth didn’t get the concept of being bi. Maybe you’ll get to see naked girls after all.”

“Maybe; but hey if there might be naked girls why didn’t you want to go?” Cody was looking at me strangely.

“Because if you look at a naked girl and get a boner; no big deal. I get a boner; Eva kills me, and then I have to date her, and become her bitch, see the difference?”

“Yeah, but you know if I do anything Eva will kill me on the spot.”

“Then I suggest you don’t cheat on your boyfriend.”

“Easy for you to say.” Cody scowled at me.

“Don’t be angry baby.” I said rolling his eyes.

“Oh look, here comes Eva!” Cody hissed at me.

I looked at him in an unsure way. I mean what was I supposed to say?                 

He rolled his eyes before leaning his head back to lie on my shoulder.

“You’re the best boyfriend ever.” He snuggled his head into the crook of my neck.

After he said that I felt a real need to say ‘I know’ but I realized that probably wouldn’t help our cause.

“You wouldn’t think that if you knew how incredible being with you is.” I said rubbing Cody’s nipple again.

“What you’re doing right now is incredible.” Cody said placing a kiss on my neck.

“And it’s only for you sexy.” I said licking his ear; he shivered.

“Sexy?”

“You like it?”

“I like everything you give me.” Cody said suggestively as he licked my cheek slowly. It was my turn to shiver.

“How did I get lucky enough to have you?”

“I was just asking myself the same thing about you.” He said turning in my lap to kiss me.

When the kiss ended he pressed his forehead to mine, and smiled.

“Does life get any better than this?” Cody asked looking me in the eyes.

“No it really doesn’t.” I said looking into his blue eyes as I ran a hand through his hair. At that moment I don’t know what happened, but my eyes were glued to his. I couldn’t look away, and our lips kept getting closer and closer. Then Cody fell out of my lap and into the water.

“Ow! Dude!” Cody screamed facing Tyler, who had just thrown a Frisbee strait into Cody’s head.

“Sorry dude! You wanna play!?” Cody looked at me.

“Go get ’em.” I said throwing a fist in the air sarcastically.

Cody rolled his eyes at me “I plan on it.” Cody kissed my lips. “Yeah, here it comes!” Cody screamed throwing the Frisbee to Tyler.

I pulled a book out of my pocket and started reading. And while I would love to say that the glances I kept giving Cody were part of the act; they defiantly weren’t. I was having trouble concentrating; I kept looking at Cody’s smile, his skinny frame, his ass. God it was all driving me insane! But I couldn’t keep from looking at him; he was becoming a drug to me. Something I couldn’t go without.

Cody leapt up and caught the Frisbee and after he threw it he looked over at me and smiled before turning back to his game.

It was like I melted into his gaze. I had to get a hold of myself. This was an act! An act Cody is only helping me with because he wants revenge. We aren’t even friends! Well maybe we are now, but…God this is confusing!

Cody once again looked at me, but this time with a concerned face. I smiled at him in a reassuring way. He shrugged and turned back around. I sighed; I was officially screwed, and no amount of denial could change my mind.